Hotels near me, Shelter Island – from 334US$

Shelter Island features popular spots like Crescent Beach, and the Shelter Island Country Club, perfect for golf enthusiasts. You can also check out the Nature Conservancy's Mashomack Preserve for stunning hikes and views of the coastline. You'll find hotels with cozy atmospheres near these attractions, from charming inns like the Havens House to comfortable stays at the Shelter Island House. This site offers a curated selection of lodging options based on great amenities and guest reviews, ensuring you pick the best place for your stay. Try to book your hotel well in advance, especially for summer weekends, to secure the best rates and availability.

1-2 out of 2

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

8.6

Great

The Pridwin Hotel

Map1.9 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 334 /nightSelect

7.8

Very good

Sunset Beach

Map1.5 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 596 /nightSelect

Places to stay near Shelter Island

7.6

Very good

West Neck Guesthouse

FromUS$ 442 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Shelter Island House

1.2 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 230 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach

1.2 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 270 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

House On Chase Creek

1.2 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 217 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

The Chequit

1.4 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 420 /nightSelect

8.6

Great

Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast

2.5 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 625 /nightSelect

8.4

Great

The Harbor Front Inn

FromUS$ 329 /nightSelect

3-star The Harbor Front Inn Greenport, located nearly a 25-minute walk from Kontokosta Winery, features a seasonal outdoor pool.

8.2

Great

The Menhaden Hotel

2.6 mi from City Centre

FromUS$ 499 /nightSelect

Price range for hotels in Shelter Island

A world of accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly stays to luxurious retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's dream vacation.

⬆️ The highest price

USD 596

⬇️ The lowest price

USD 334

💸 Average price for

4-star hotels

USD 465

Hotel Insights for Shelter Island Travelers

This guide provides essential information about hotels in Shelter Island, evaluating 2 unique properties to help travelers make informed decisions regarding their accommodations.

Typical nightly prices range from $200 to $350 USD.

Shelter Island features 2 main hotel properties.

Peak travel seasons are late spring and summer months.

Local taxes and fees total approximately 12%.

Distance to the Shelter Island Ferry is about 1.5 km.

Hotels Near Me in Shelter Island

Stay Close to the City’s Top Sights and Connections in Shelter Island, United States

Places to stay near Shelter Island

Shelter Island Heights5 properties

Greenport3 properties

Price range for hotels in Shelter Island

Hotel Insights for Shelter Island Travelers

Other cities in United States