Shelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights Exterior photoShelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights Interior photoShelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights Exterior photo
Book on our site
up to 10% cheaper
than Booking.com
Check rooms and rates
From569US$ /night
Check-in
03May2026Select date
Check-out
04May2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Hotel

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
-
A block from Sunset Beach
Great
8.7
/10
4.7
4.5
/5

Located 3.4 km from the Greenport Village, Shelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights offers amenities such as a sun terrace and a shared lounge. Featuring a restaurant, the hotel is within a 10-minute drive of the Southold Bay.

Location

The centre of Shelter Island Heights can be reached within a 15-minute walk, and natural attractions like the Mashomack Preserve are 3.8 km away. The Lavender By the Bay is about 15 minutes by car from the Shelter Island House Shelter Island Heights, while East Hampton is 19 km away.

This 4-star hotel also provides access to shopping attractions like the Beall & Bell antique shop, which are 3.5 km away.

Long Island MacArthur airport is 85 km away from the property.

Rooms

There are 11 rooms at Shelter Island House Hotel, each of them has air conditioning, as well as entertainment amenities such as a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. Bathroom comforts include hair dryers and free toiletries, and such essentials as a separate toilet and a shower. Guests can enjoy views of the garden from the hotel.

Eat & Drink

You can dine at Shelter Island House, around 5 minutes' walk away.

Leisure & Business

A seasonal outdoor swimming pool with a pool cover is provided on site. This property offers a range of activities such as cycling and table tennis.

Must-do experiences

  • Stroll through the quiet trails of Mashomack Preserve for nature bliss.
  • Visit the historicShelter Island Lighthouse for stunning sunset views.
  • Try the fresh oysters at the Chequit's outdoor bar by the water.
  • Explore the arts at the Shelter Island Historical Society museum.
  • Join a local fishing charter for a unique experience on the water.
View all

Select your room type

Shelter Island House Hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
King Suite
2 persons
420 sq. feet 
1 King-size bed
Shower
Heating
Queen Room
2 persons
250 sq. feet 
1 Double bed
Shower
Heating
Deluxe King Room
2 persons
270 sq. feet 
1 King-size bed
Shower
Heating
Double Queen Room
2 persons
455 sq. feet 
2 King Size Beds
Shower
Heating
Click button to see more rooms
Show all rooms
Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

Shelter Island House Hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Facilities: Very good
7.9/10Review score

General

  • No smoking on site
  • Free Wi-Fi in public areas
  • Parking
  • Safe deposit box
  • Pets allowed
  • Luggage storage

Sports & Fitness

  • Cycling

Services

  • Housekeeping

Dining

  • Restaurant
  • Snack bar
  • Bar/ Lounge area
  • Picnic area/ Tables

Children

  • Cots
  • Board games

Spa & Leisure

  • Seasonal outdoor pool
  • Beach access
  • Sun terrace
  • Garden area
  • Leisure/ TV room
  • Massage
  • Shallow end

Room features

  • Air conditioning
  • Heating
  • Sitting area
  • Garden furniture
  • Dining table

Bathroom

  • Free toiletries

Media

  • Flat-screen TV
  • AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

  • Parquet floor
Show more

Shelter Island House Hotel Location

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
Map view
11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States
Nearby
Shelter Island Country Club
1900 ft
Golf Course
Shelter Island Golf Course
1900 ft
Sunset Beach
1900 ft
Restaurants
Eagle Deli
2200 ft
25 W Neck Rd
Getting around
City Centre
Shelter Island Heights16 min  ·  4300 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur (ISP)127 min  ·  52.3 mi
Republic (FRG)169 min  ·  70.0 mi
Interested in Nearby Hotel Rates?
Live prices. No outdated rates
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 15:00-22:00
Check-out
from 07:00-11:00
Guest Parking
Private parking is possible on site for free.
Internet
Wireless internet is available in public areas for free.
Children & extra beds
Maximum capacity of extra beds in a room is 1. 
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Number of rooms:
11

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Shelter Island House Hotel from previous guests about their experience.
Review score
Based on 4 verified reviews
9.3/10
Perfect
100%
Recommend
Cleanliness
8.3/10
Comfort
8.7/10
Facilities
7.9/10
Location
9.2/10
Staff
8.7/10
Value for money
7.9/10
Guest reviews
based on 7 reviews
8.7/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.
Open reviews
Check-in
03May2026Select date
Check-out
04May2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room